Let's call this an experiment...

What do you call a fic that's not a fic

Moderators: Hagus, SeanWolf

Locked
User avatar
Shiro
Posts: 22
Joined: Tue Dec 22, 2009 10:39 am
Location: Side 3

Let's call this an experiment...

Post by Shiro »

So, I typed this thing out a little after Christmas. It was going to be part of a larger story, but as so often happens I gave up halfway through the chapter and just saved what I had for reference or something. Now once again I'm trying to write a fanfic, but I tend to be very critical of myself, often rereading any sentence or paragraph I just finished and trying to completely perfect it. Then I loose my train of thought or get depressed and give up. It happens every freaking time.

Anyway, this time I'm forcing myself to hold off on the polishing phase until I actually finish the blasted draft. But I know my "style" probably needs tons of work, and that there's a bunch of flaws I'm not seeing. So I'm posting this fragment in hopes of getting some helpful criticism. Frankly, I'm too afraid to show this to anyone (reliable) that I know, and that's where the anonymity of the internet comes in. So please, pretty please, with sugar and world domination on top, could you read and review? :cry:

***

“Oh, having a good time are we?”

King didn't answer Pete's probably rhetorical question. In fact, he refused to give any sign that he had even heard the bird-freak. Instead he focused on the increasingly difficult task of guiding his virtual avatar across a barren wasteland—one infested with tons of ridiculously oversized monsters. He jammed one of the thumb pads of his controller to the side, but that wasn't fast enough to keep his character from being squashed underfoot. For the twentieth time in six minutes, and by the same nasty creature to boot.

King's mood was not improved when he felt Pete sit down beside him. The couch was easily big enough for the two of them, what with King being one of the smaller breeds of dogs. The fact that Pete was faithfully keeping to his human form helped, too. But that didn't mean King liked being anywhere near his self-appointed guardian. Ignoring Pete wasn't enough to rile the “man” up, but King half hoped he would grow bored of his unrequited taunting and go pick on somebody else. Surely the griffin-in-disguise couldn't be satisfied with ruining only one person's life? Or did he actually think he was helping King? Either way, King couldn't help but fold his ears back at Pete's approach.

“So, what are we playing today on...what was this thing called again?”

“Xbox 360,” King answered tonelessly. As if you don't actually know, he snarled mentally. At least be decent enough to drop the Ignorant Act. King had been especially cross with Pete ever since his little Christmas morning pep talk, if that was what it could be called. King was pretty sure by now that any supposed concern the creature had for him was totally fake; more to lull him into a precarious sense of semi-endearment or thankfulness than anything else. Pretending that King knew something he didn't was just throwing him a bone.

King glanced from the television to the game console. Case in point. It seemed just a little too nice that Pete had gotten him the thing for Christmas. He supposed that, given the model's high failure rate (and the fact that this particular unit had "mysteriously" not come with a warranty), Pete had seen some opportunities for ironic cruelty. Stupid sadistic bird. Plus, King had really wanted a PS3 instead.

If Pete had some kind of mind reading powers King didn't know about, he did a good job of hiding it. “And what is this particular game?” he asked pleasantly

“One you would probably suck at.” However futile it was, King did get some small satisfaction out of verbally combating Pete. Little practical good came of it, but it was something none the less.

“Oh, I don't know about that. But more to the point, you've spent almost all day cooped up inside. I think it's time you went out and played with your friends.”

King stubbornly kept his eyes on the screen. “It's cold and overcast, plus a ton of rain's supposed to be coming in sometime today. No one is going to be outside. There won't be anything to do. I'll be bored out of my skull.”

“Yet you still need the exercise,” Pete rejoined without a hint of annoyance at King's obstinacy. “I'm sure you will find at least one of your little pals.”

“I don't have any 'pals,' okay? I have acquaintances.”

Pete sighed melodramatically. “Oh, yes, I forgot. Somehow, in the month we've been here, you've only managed to make one genuine friend.” He moved closer to an increasingly uncomfortable King. “You know, it would be in your best interests if you were a tad more social. Your little ordeal would be far more enjoyable.”

When Pete stretched out his arm and tried to scratch King behind the ears, the dog promptly scooted out of reach. This only served to amuse rather than annoy the creature. “All the same, you're going out there. Whether by choice or force is up to you.” Apparently feeling the need to illustrate his point, Pete snapped his fingers, and King suddenly found himself standing at the front door, black scarf in paw.

King didn't like any of the suggestions Pete threw his way, and he certainly didn't enjoy how the bird pushed him around. But what he truly hated, at least at the moment, was the idea of spending another second with him. That desire outweighed all others.

He gritted his teeth, but still managed a curt, “Fine, whatever.”

King threw the scarf around his neck and turned to the door. He had only just put his paw on the brass knob when Pete called from the couch, “Make sure to be back by six. I wanted you to try a new brand of dog food I found in the grocery bargain bin today. It's generic, and a little out of date, but I'm sure it couldn't be that bad. No skipping out on supper tonight, now.”

King suppressed a growl as he turned the knob. He'd be out of here soon enough, and there was no point in arguing. Even so, Pete wasn't quite finished.

“And one more thing,” the bird added, index finger raised as if he had just remembered something. “The storm is supposed to come in sometime before evening. Do be back before that; I don't very much care for the scent of wet dog, so if you don't want to spend the night in the garage....” He trailed off.

King thought he saw a slight smirk on Pete's face, though his mustache obscured it. King sent him a glare and quickly made his way outside. He really, really hated that bird.

* * *

While King had been introduced to nearly every dog in the neighborhood, Fox was still the one he knew—and liked—the best. As such, he was also the one King spent most of his time around. Frankly, King was surprised just how well they had hit it off, considering their past history. Well, maybe it wasn't so odd if one didn't think about that. Who knew how Fox would react if he knew King was actually, uh, whoever he had been before meeting Pete.

King kicked aside a pebble as he tread down the sidewalk. Blast it, why couldn't he remember his own name? Yes, that was something else he could blame Pete for, but that didn't change the fact that, somehow, his actual birth name had been totally blocked from his memory. It was probably in there somewhere, buried away; King had once spent an entire day trying to write it down, though the farthest he'd gotten was the word “joking.”

His eyes narrowed. How was any of this fair? If there was a God, why did He let Pete just waltz right into his life and start rearranging everything on a whim? Was this supposed to be justice? Because of what he had done to Fox? That was what prison had been for! Yes, he appreciate some aspects of his new life, but what gave Pete the right to do anything to him? The monster had violated his rightful physical form, amalgamated his basic identity, and stripped him of any shred of dignity he could have otherwise retained. Wasn't toying with people for your own sick amusement a sin as well? Where was the justice in that?!

King sighed as he continued on his way. Technically he had given Pete permission to do...something or other, back when the two had first met. But Pete hadn't gone with the plan that King had agreed to, so didn't that void any possible “contract” they could have? Besides, at the time, King had thought Pete to be part a dream, or maybe a hallucination. Now he was pretty certain that wasn't the case.

And that just makes this all the more crazy!
King was beginning to grow angry, a feeling that compounded with each new thought. Even if that stupid bird hadn't tricked me into this, he would've just gone ahead and done it anyway. He doesn't care! He never did! King was almost fuming by now. This was never about reforming me, was it? I swear, if I ever find out who let that, that thing out into the world, I'll—

“Hey, King! You okay?”

King jerked his head up. Apparently, he had been too deep in thought to notice that he'd arrived at his destination. Fox was up on a ladder in front of the garage door. Part of a string of Christmas lights hung limply from the edge of the gutter down to the driveway; the rest of the candescent chain was still in its place, linked with a few others so as to fully encircle the house. Or at least King figured as much. Only the front yard and sides of the house were visible from the street, and he had never been in the back yard; he was still too uneasy around Fox's owner for that.

“Uh, ye-yeah,” King returned. “I'm fine. Why'd you ask?”

Fox shrugged, but didn't lose the look of concern. “You looked pretty mad about something, that's all. Is it something you want to talk about?”

King waved the question away. “Nah, it's no big deal. Pete and I just got into an argument this morning.” He quickly changed the subject. “So why are you taking down the lights? Isn't that something for your Dad to do?”

“Yeah, well, it was at one point.” Fox turned back to his task of unclipping the string, but continued talking. “A couple of years ago Dad broke his leg when he tried chasing down a suspect. I ended up having to do a lot of the chores for a while, so I just volunteered to take care of this too. Dad never could remember to do it anyway, so I sort of turned it into a tradition.” Fox chuckled a little. “If I did leave it to dad, these things would be up till July!”

King smiled. That was another thing he liked about Fox. He thought of others and often tried to go the extra mile. King kind of wished he could be more like that, at least someday. On that matter, he wasn't too pleased when he remembered Pete's advice on “the journey of a thousand miles,” but he couldn't argue its truth. Better to start in that direction now rather than never.

“Want some help?” he asked in his most helper-ish voice.

“Seriously?” Fox suddenly looked extremely relieved. “Yeah, thank you, that would be great. It's a real pain taking all this down by myself. But it should be quick work between the two of us.”

Then he glanced up at the sky, and his smile collapsed into a frown. “We need to hurry, though.”

King followed the other dog's gaze. The gray canopy had indeed gotten darker on the short trip over there. Off in the distance, even darker banks of cloud could be seen coming towards them. King wasn't too good at estimating time according to distance and speed, but he doubted they had more than two hours before the downpour hit.

Fox was partly right. Their progress wasn't as great as King would have liked, but they neared the finishing point soon enough. After half an hour there was only one small section to go. King was on top of the ladder with Fox holding it steady down below. Unfortunately, this was one of those times that King's lack of height reared its inconvenient head.

“Come on, come on,” King growled as he reached up toward the string. It was just out of reach, so long as he stayed on the last safe rung.

“Let's just switch places, okay King?” Fox offered.

“No, hold on, I can do this,” King said stubbornly. He moved to rise up just one more step before pausing abruptly. That's weird....

“Hey, Fox? I think your wire's defective.”

“Huh?”

“The insulation is missing.” King pointed to a significant length of bare copper. “Was it like this when you put it up?”

Fox shook his head as he moved to get a better look. “No. Dad's the one who actually puts the lights up every year, but he'd never use something with an exposed wire, and I don't think he'd miss anything that big.”

King glanced from Fox back to the wire. “So what do you think did this? Squirrels, maybe?”

The gray dog shrugged. “I dunno, I kind of think—hey! What are you doing?!”

King stepped to the top of the ladder and stretched up on his tiptoes. His ability to balance up here left much to be desired, but at least he could grasp the lights now. “Relax, I'll be fine.”

“No!” Fox objected. “Just trade places with me. Better safe than sorry.”

“I'm telling you, I'm fine,” King argued, trying hard to hide the wobble in his legs. He could do this. Here was at least one thing in his life he still had control over. It didn't matter if he was artificially short. It didn't matter if his old body had been stolen away. He didn't care if he was being petty or childish about this. He wasn't going to let any of that stop him, flower power!

Fox tried a different angle. “Look, it's going to rain any minute now.” True to his words, large swaths of the sky had turned nearly black. The daylight had diminished quite a bit since the pair's task began, and it was only because of the size of the injury that King had spotted the damaged wire in the first place.


Fox continued, “Let's just leave this for later, okay? I can take care of this tomorrow myself, two minutes flat. Meanwhile,” he added, smiling, “Dad rented the new Star Trek, and he lets me work the popcorn maker. So, if it's okay with your person, do you think you could....”

“...Sleep over?” King supplied hopefully. He still wasn't too keen on going back home, even for the night. Besides, he really wanted to see that movie. Being in jail had kind of foiled him during the theatrical release.

Fox shrugged happily. “Sure, why not? I didn't have any plans anyway.”

That pretty much settled it for King. He took a step down from his perch.

Still....

He cast a glance up at that last section of lights. Two minutes, right? He could save Fox the trouble if he just did it himself. Another glance, this time down at his expectant friend, and he reached a determined paw back up. What was the worst two measly minutes could do?

Then it started to rain. Hard. Almost before King could comprehend the irony, his short fur coat was thoroughly drenched. Which, on a warm summer day, wouldn't have been a bad thing, had King been a dog long enough to have learned to appreciate (or at least grown accustomed to) this sort of thing. But that was most certainly not the case now. King could barely stand the way his fur was matting to his skin. Even worse, the water was acting as an insulator in reverse; he shivered violently as the heat rapidly drained from his skin. Fox, it seemed, shared his distress at their current situation.

“Gaaah! That's cold!,” Fox half shrieked, trying his best to stay under the eves of the house while still holding the ladder steady. “King, please come down,” he begged.

***

Aaaaaand, that's it. That's as far as I got while still considering it decent. Any comments will be enormously appreciated (though the more in-depth, the better). :)
[Insert clever quote and/or saying here]
User avatar
The Game
Posts: 3920
Joined: Wed Nov 25, 2009 4:28 pm

Re: Let's call this an experiment...

Post by The Game »

hey, that's pretty good! I enjoyed reading this.
I can't find anything to criticize, other than...wait no that was perfect. it's really good, you get 10! (out of 10)
User avatar
Icharus
Posts: 226
Joined: Sat Jan 02, 2010 11:20 pm
Location: Californ-eye-yay
Contact:

Re: Let's call this an experiment...

Post by Icharus »

Only one typo to note, here:
Shiro wrote: Yes, he appreciated some aspects of his new life, but what gave Pete the right to do anything to him
Great story! It is nice getting some characterisation for Fox, since there's not all that much from the comic. Your "style" definitely brings out these characters' personalities, which is good.

It seems that you suffer the same thing I do, regarding the top of your post. I don't know how many works of fiction/ fanfiction I've tried to write where I spent six notebook pages on a single scene trying to perfect it, and then never finishing the rest of the story, or mapping out an entire story plus writing a dozen character bios, and then the idea gets abandoned.
Also, right there with ya on the "more comfortable with web-anonymity" thing.
Image
Image
Image
User avatar
Barkeron
Posts: 870
Joined: Tue Jan 05, 2010 12:01 pm
Contact:

Re: Let's call this an experiment...

Post by Barkeron »

You captured Joel/King's personally quite well. Great story. Is there going to be more?
User avatar
Shiro
Posts: 22
Joined: Tue Dec 22, 2009 10:39 am
Location: Side 3

Re: Let's call this an experiment...

Post by Shiro »

First of all, thank you The Game, Icharus, and Barkeron for reviewing. Your time and comments are very appreciated.

It sounds like I'm doing okay, but then I look at how many people have viewed the thread without saying anything (yes, I know that's not unusual for any thread). Still, I start to wonder.... I mean, did I just scare everyone off with the introduction? Do most people think my stuff isn't worth comment? Or do they agree with you guys and just not see any point in commenting further? I've been guilty of all three, plus being incurably lazy....

Well, in any case, I trust your guys' judgment, so I'll go ahead with what I'm writing right now.
Barkeron wrote:Is there going to be more?
I probably won't be adding to this fragment, or at least not anytime soon. See, what I was trying to do was combine Housepets! with inFAMOUS (I got the game for Christmas and enjoyed it a lot. So sue me) but remembered then I was already working on something else. I have to force myself to keep on track with just one project at a time or nothing gets done. Maybe when I'm done with the current project, and if I'm still interested, I'll come back and finish this. I kind of like the idea of King with lightning powers. Plus he'd look adorable in that yellow jacket.

And again to all three of you...THANK YOU!!!!!
[Insert clever quote and/or saying here]
User avatar
ChewyChewy
Posts: 5460
Joined: Wed Feb 24, 2010 3:23 pm

Re: Let's call this an experiment...

Post by ChewyChewy »

I can sympathize with your insecurity (I've been that way myself) but I'm sure you didn't "scare" ANYONE off. :P And I doubt they think it isn't worth commenting on. For my part I don't often read things like this anyway so it's not anything personal (especially since Fox and King are my favorite characters). I literally only just read it now.

I'll be happy to tell you what I thought, though, now that I've read it.

First of all, I'm jealous because I wrote a prose adaptation of "It's a Wonderful Dog's Life" and it's not as good as your writing which is original. Yours is better and feels more like the characters and the world are real, almost like Rick Griffin wrote it himself.

I liked the jokes about "throwing him a bone" and how he tried to write his name and it came out "joking." Those were funny.

I agree that you did get the personalities of King and Fox down pat, less sure about Pete. He didn't come across quite that sadistic in the comic. Granted, you could have done a lot worse with it, so that's not too big a criticism. Also, I interpret the situation a little differently from how you did but that's not a criticism because that's subjective--all we have to go by is what's in the comic.

I'm a little perplexed by King calling Pete by his name (rather than "Dad") without commentary either from Fox or in the narration. Likewise, why does Fox say "your person" instead of "your owner" or "your dad"?

I also noticed one grammar error: "King kicked aside a pebble as he tread down the sidewalk." I think it's supposed to be "trod."

If I have any real complaints it's the ending--in particular, how there IS no ending and the dogs are drenched and King is still on the ladder. Then again, I was afraid he might get ELECTROCUTED and was relieved when he didn't. The Star Trek thing bugs me a little but that's just a personal thing and not a legitimate criticism.

In all, I'm only sad that you're not going to continue this. :( I want to see what happens next!
Image
PF chars

"We have to do this take again! HAL, do it with a LOT less emotion!"
"I'm sorry Stan, I'm afraid I can't do that."
--Phoenix

pair-o-dimes dot blogspot dot com
User avatar
Shiro
Posts: 22
Joined: Tue Dec 22, 2009 10:39 am
Location: Side 3

Re: Let's call this an experiment...

Post by Shiro »

Hi, ChewyChewy! It's always good to have a fellow fanfic writer give constructive criticism (and I'm quite pleased with the thoroughness of your assessment). Thank you for reviewing!
ChewyChewy wrote:First of all, I'm jealous because I wrote a prose adaptation of "It's a Wonderful Dog's Life" and it's not as good as your writing which is original. Yours is better and feels more like the characters and the world are real, almost like Rick Griffin wrote it himself.
Doooooohhhhhh... *looks away bashfully* It can't be that good. Surely you jest.
ChewyChewy wrote:I'm a little perplexed by King calling Pete by his name (rather than "Dad") without commentary either from Fox or in the narration. Likewise, why does Fox say "your person" instead of "your owner" or "your dad"?
Yeah, I was going to get to the Pete-not-Dad thing later on in the chapter (or maybe just try to splice it into what I had), but like I said, what I posted is just a fragment. Basically, I can't really imagine King ever calling Pete "Dad." He'd rather choke himself with a garden hose than use any possible term of endearment (I assume). To outside observers (like Fox) it would just look like the two had a dysfunctional relationship (which, of course, is completely true). As for the owner/person thing, well, yeah, I totally overlooked that. Thanks for pointing it out.
ChewyChewy wrote:If I have any real complaints it's the ending--in particular, how there IS no ending and the dogs are drenched and King is still on the ladder. Then again, I was afraid he might get ELECTROCUTED and was relieved when he didn't.
I guess I should have just finished the chapter and posted the whole thing, but it was supposed to be around three times as long as now, and I wanted useful feedback (like your own :) ) so I posted what I had. It probably wasn't the most thoughtful thing to do, though. And on the electrocution thing...you probably wouldn't have felt relieved if I had posted the complete product. Cause, you know...inFAMOUS...lightning powers.... I had to have them come from somewhere, with some added handwaving and techno magibabble to explain how that would even work. Then again, that might not be your cup of tea....
ChewyChewy wrote:The Star Trek thing bugs me a little but that's just a personal thing and not a legitimate criticism.
The funny thing is, I was actually a whole lot more worried about people getting mad at me over the PS3 vs. X-Box 360 preference. Curve ball out of nowhere, I guess.
ChewyChewy wrote:In all, I'm only sad that you're not going to continue this. :( I want to see what happens next!
Despite what I said before, now I'm all conflicted! I mean, I do want to work on this, but I know giving up on my other 'fic is just asking for failure. Maybe I should try doing both at the same time?

I dunno, what do you think? The current project is a sort of Mobile Suit Gundam/Housepets! fusion deal. Which sounds really weird and nigh impossible, I'm sure. So what do you think most people would like to see: Peanut in a Gundam, King with lightning powers, or neither?
[Insert clever quote and/or saying here]
User avatar
ChewyChewy
Posts: 5460
Joined: Wed Feb 24, 2010 3:23 pm

Re: Let's call this an experiment...

Post by ChewyChewy »

You're welcome! :D

Well, tell you what--read mine (not entirely up, two parts more) and then tell me if you think I'm jesting.

I guess that didn't occur to me, although I personally would have commented on it somehow....

Ah, okay, I guess I didn't know what you were going for.... That might not have been my thing, I'll grant.... :oops:

I just hated the new Star Trek movie--that seems to be just me, though....

I know the feeling, and I didn't mean to put you in that situation.... :( Just follow your Muse. ;)
Image
PF chars

"We have to do this take again! HAL, do it with a LOT less emotion!"
"I'm sorry Stan, I'm afraid I can't do that."
--Phoenix

pair-o-dimes dot blogspot dot com
User avatar
valerio
Posts: 19330
Joined: Mon May 25, 2009 6:53 am
Location: Italy
Contact:

Re: Let's call this an experiment...

Post by valerio »

...I missed this wonderful piece for so long?!?
I'm sorry you haven't continued it, Shiro. If you can read this, I'm sure you would've made a nice addition to the ATKM contest.
Here's hoping you'll make a return with shining colors. All the best! :D
Image
User avatar
Karl
Posts: 1664
Joined: Sun Sep 12, 2010 7:27 pm
Location: Singing Fortepiano

Re: Let's call this an experiment...

Post by Karl »

I'm really upset that there is no continuation of this story. I must say that it really hooked my attention, althought I knew that it was abandoned.

I know that it's been a long time since you were active last time, but I hope that one day you will check forums to see how are things going.

And as people said, you did well with catching personalities as they are in strips. Especially Pete. In my opinion, that is how he exactly behaves towards King. Very well done :)
Shiro wrote:Now once again I'm trying to write a fanfic, but I tend to be very critical of myself, often rereading any sentence or paragraph I just finished and trying to completely perfect it. Then I loose my train of thought or get depressed and give up. It happens every freaking time.
I understand how it feels. It keeps happening to me too, and I'm sure that a lot of writers around the world have the same problem. But I'm telling myself that I really should try, otherwise I might regret not sharing my imagination with others. You just have to be strong and believe in yourself. I bet that even Mozart felt fear before his first concerts.

Also it comes up with trainings. If you keep up on writing, you might be able to pass the artistic block that attacks your mind. And it always works with small footsteps on beginning.
I'm a bookworm!
User avatar
valerio
Posts: 19330
Joined: Mon May 25, 2009 6:53 am
Location: Italy
Contact:

Re: Let's call this an experiment...

Post by valerio »

Karlos is totally right. Heh, my first ficcies came on a piece of paper -no, I mean it, I'd write on a ring binder, there wasn't the internet! I had stacked workbooks thickly written and man that stuff was AWFUL. I trashed them with my first moving, though I do regret it a bit now...
But the point is, Shiro, if you ever read this, this ficcie was really good and it's a shame you abandoned it. Hope you'll rethink about it.
Image
User avatar
alejandro
Posts: 15
Joined: Wed Nov 17, 2010 8:53 am

Re: Let's call this an experiment...

Post by alejandro »

I like this.

If you need help, I'd be happy to oblige.
Locked