Avatar: The gif alternates now, cool 10/10
Siggy: 10/10 precocious still ftw

(Btw, if you haven't noticed, the glittertext on my avie says "The Flaw" with an arrow pointing at Max's left ear for Rick forgot to make the bite in Max's ear once again on this Friday's Strip.)

avy: now that i see the arrow: 9/10
siggy: still funny 8/10

I'm going to perform one more life saving measure on this thread...
Avatar (Hyperbola)
6/10, I understand the context of the original image, but without it it's kinda random.

Signature
8/10, I've already listed stuff I don't like about it, so I'll just say the bars of ='s are an improvement.

Avatar: boofy hair man with fist to head in black and white. 6/10
Siggy: meh...

Avie: 8/10 pic
Siggy: 8/10 (pink?)

Avvy: Zander:9/10
Siggy:Same... The avvy count is going up...

Neil Gaiman looks cool according to wikipedia.

Iss tru, Mac und me went to retrieve a pink golf ball and we could feel it! Or it was the heat...

Avatar
Would be 8/10, but the new size* isn't doing it any favors; you're getting fuzzy there. So I'll go with 6/10

Signature
8/10 for cool userbars.

*There is a new avatar size, right? I haven't just gone insane?

Avatar (There She Is): 8/10

Signature: 7/10
because you misspelled "Tarot."

Avatar: 7/10 (Doesn't exactly fit my taste but still a good drawing)
Sig: 8/10 (Also wish I could afford the comissions)

Avie: 9/10 (New comic avvie)
Siggy: 7/10 (Brings sadness to one's eyes)

Avatar: 6/10, maybe it's just my screen, but it looks pixelated.

Signature: 8/10, too many userbars, but that is all forgiven for the broom to your face.

Mine is dynamic, but you don't really have to specify because they're all mostly the same.

Avatar: This is the first time I have seen the one with those Precocious characters in the mud. 10/10
Siggy: U stoolllzzz my eye-d-ah 4 teh mueving imge lololololool. <Joke> 10/10 as always of recently.
~
Yes, the only reason I am posting here is so you rate my new avvy.

Avatar: 3/10. Your drawing skills have improved since you drew that, so it looks kind of dated.

Signature: 6/10. Daft Punk is pretty rad, and I like harmless pranks like the fake fly. I can't rate it too high, though, or else I'll only be encouraging your Precocious addiction.

Avatar: Cookies
9/10, yup

Signature: The ever elusive Androgyny sig!
8/10, not as good as the other one.
But I do like the random shipping bars so that got you an extra point or two.

Avatar: 9/10 I do actually like it, but it just took me ages to figure out a)what it was, and b) why it's eyes were like that.

Signature: 5/10, I just don't understand what it means. Or what that monster thing is.

Avatar: 7/10 Is that a dictionary?
Signature: 9/10 Yay Fox!

I get this a lot. I'm not insulted in the slightest, but Chipmunks do have eye markings. I just stylized them ridiculously to the point that he looks like a raccoon

And the sigs are Spore creatures, what they "mean" is classified information known only to workers in Sector C.

Alex-
Avatar (Skull): 9/10
It's colorful and cooliotastic, also very distinctly Mexican. 'sCool.

Signature: 8/10
I love your signatures; I'm just going to nit-pick and point out that "red" is a color, "read" (as in read a book) has an a. This can probably get confusing though, because the past tense of "read" is pronounced like "red."

That's was a faulty typo from my part

Avatar: 10/10 I love the 3-D effect on your avatars.
Signature: 8/10 Some of that Spore creatures are creepy >.>

Avvy: It is impossible not to like that. 10/10
Siggy: It gives off a bad aura.... 10/10
^ I didn't realise it rotated... ^-^'

AVATAR
6/10, it's funny the first time, but I keep being distracted by what narrow margins that dictionary has.

SIGNATURE
7/10, sparse, but I prefer this to overcrowded. One userbar and some text is a pretty good length for a signature I say.

Avatar: I like it. 9/10
Signature: I never liked that Joey quote. ALSO YOU AQZ( a-cue-z get it? accuse) ME OF BEEN BAD PERSON 4 NOT GOING ON THE INTERWEBZZZ TO DUW SUMTHIK CONSTRUCTIVE!!!!1!!111!!!! 4/10

I'm gunna change my avatar now... See if you can post before I do.

Avatar: 9.9/10 (She's gonna die someday falling off that house like a butterfly...)
Siggy: 9.9/10 (Rotating Yvette should be burnt...)

(Ok, just PM me, ok? Also, you have to understand the "can" and "may" true usage of it)
Avatar: 9/10 (Now she's just scared)
Siggy: 9.9/10 (Almost there...)

Avatar: 9/10 (Yes, that one.)
Siggy: 9.9/10 (Still awesome)

Avatar: 9/10 (Bleach girl...)
Siggy: 9/10